Step-In vs. Overhead Dog Harness: Which Is Better?

Choosing the right harness can make all the difference during walkies—both for your dog’s comfort and your own ease of use.

Two of the most common styles are the step-in harness and the overhead harness. But which one is better for your dog?

Let’s compare the two based on comfort, ease of use, and walking behaviour—so you can pick the one that suits your pup best.

🐾 What Is a Step-In Harness?

A step-in harness is designed for your dog to step into with their front legs. You then pull it up and fasten it over the back.

✅ Pros:

• Ideal for dogs who dislike things going over their head
• Easy to put on if your dog stays still
• Distributes pressure evenly around the chest

⚠️ Things to consider:

• Can be tricky with wriggly dogs
• Might not fit as snugly on deep-chested breeds
• May shift during walks if not adjusted properly

These work well for smaller dogs or those with sensitive necks. If your pup’s not a fan of overhead gear, a step-in tweed harness could be just right.

🐕 What Is an Overhead Harness?

With this style, the harness goes over your dog’s head and clips under the belly or at the side.

✅ Pros:

• Often more secure and less likely to slip
• Better for dogs who pull on the lead
• Adjustable fit across multiple points

⚠️ Things to consider:

• Not ideal for dogs with neck sensitivity
• Can be fiddly if your dog doesn’t like things over their head
• Needs more adjustment the first time you use it

Our bundle sets often include matching overhead harnesses and leads, great for confident walkers.

🐶 Which One Is Right for Your Dog?

Here’s a quick guide:

Still unsure? Our blog on how to choose the right lead for your dog’s walking style pairs well with this to help you build a full walking setup.

🧵 Material and Comfort Matter Too

Regardless of the type, make sure the harness is:

• Padded for comfort
• Breathable to avoid overheating
• Adjustable so it sits snugly without chafing

Tweed harnesses lined with soft cotton are ideal for dogs with sensitive skin. You can explore our full tweed collection for handmade, dog-friendly options.

💡 Pro Tip: Have Both on Hand

Many pet parents find it handy to own both styles. Use a step-in harness for quick errands and calm walks, and an overhead one for longer walks or more energetic outings.

💬 Final Thoughts

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The best harness depends on your dog’s size, behaviour, and comfort needs.

Take a bit of time to observe your pup’s reaction to each style, and you’ll soon know what makes their walk time easier and more enjoyable.

🛍️ Ready to shop? Browse our dog harness collection to find the perfect fit for your pup’s walking style.